| February 26, | 2024 | Jack Supron | |
| November 6 | 2023 | Isaac Smith | |
| January 23 | 2023 | Adam Cobb | Bronze Palm |
| December 12 | 2022 | Matthew Schmidt | |
| October 3 | 2022 | Kyle Bruce | Bronze Palm |
| August 22 | 2022 | Henry Darius Exline | Bronze & Gold Palms |
| July 11 | 2022 | Cameron Smith | Bronze Palm |
| April 18 | 2022 | Nicholas H. Boriin | Bronze & Gold Palms |
| April 6 | 2022 | Luke S. Niese | Bronze & Gold Palms |
| December 6 | 2021 | Max Jacob Fauth | |
| November 15 | 2021 | Benjamin R. Stone | Bronze (2), Gold (2), & Silver Palms |
| April 5 | 2021 | Benjamin Leffler | Bronze & Gold Palms |
| December 15 | 2020 | Justin D Darling | Bronze Palm |
| July 13 | 2020 | Matthew Niese | Bronze & Gold Palms |
| February 17 | 2020 | Andrew G Hindall | |
| January 27 | 2020 | Harrison Blake | Bronze & Gold Palms |
| July 9 | 2019 | Jacob Strous | Bronze, Gold & Silver Palms |
| April 22 | 2019 | Ethan Hughes | |
| February 18 | 2019 | Willem Black | |
| August 14 | 2018 | Benjamin T. Niese | Bronze, Gold & Silver Palms |
| July 23 | 2018 | Benedict N. Noonan | Bronze & Gold Palms |
| July 10 | 2017 | Christopher J. Thode | |
| July 10 | 2017 | William G. Foster | |
| April 10 | 2017 | Daniel Cobb | |
| March 21 | 2017 | Justin Mascarin | |
| October 4 | 2016 | Nicholas Green | |
| August 9 | 2016 | Anthony Smith | |
| July 11 | 2016 | Ethan Black | |
| April 27 | 2016 | David Darling | |
| December 8 | 2015 | Christian Shrake | |
| August 10 | 2015 | Aaron Hunt | |
| May 11 | 2015 | Nicholas Gasior | |
| March 31 | 2015 | Christopher Chapman | |
| March 30 | 2015 | Matthew Smith | |
| February 23 | 2015 | Jacob Robinson | |
| July 24 | 2014 | Alexander W. Hoyt | |
| February 19 | 2014 | Riley J. Hull | |
| January 14 | 2014 | Christopher W. Dickman | |
| November 19 | 2013 | Devin C. Chapman | |
| August 12 | 2013 | Rylee B. Crimmel | |
| May 13 | 2013 | David R. Soller | Michael Vail Eagle of the Year Award |
| March 5 | 2013 | Colin J. O’Brien | |
| February 5 | 2013 | Jospeh R. Daniel | |
| September 25 | 2012 | Andrew M. Barlage | Michael Vail Eagle of the Year Award |
| September 18 | 2012 | Stephen R. Weisenberger | |
| May 29 | 2012 | Benjamin E. Natarian | |
| October 25 | 2011 | Peter J. Fiala | |
| July 20 | 2011 | Albert J. Darling | |
| January 26 | 2011 | Brent A. Eastman | |
| December 7 | 2010 | George R. Domer | |
| October 5 | 2010 | Kenneth J. Ness | |
| November 16 | 2009 | Brian A. Jones | |
| May 12 | 2009 | Neil P. Rischl | |
| April 16 | 2009 | Christopher M. Bender | |
| February 4 | 2009 | David V. Gallick | |
| December 22 | 2008 | Allen W. Hoyt | |
| August 18 | 2008 | Mark P. Weisenberger | |
| April 24 | 2008 | Jeremy A. Herman | |
| April 16 | 2008 | Ethan Newman | |
| February 27 | 2008 | Joshua T. Jones | |
| December 17 | 2007 | Charles P. Daughters | Michael Vail Eagle of the Year Award |
| November 14 | 2007 | Bradley R. Jones | |
| March 27 | 2007 | Anthony J. Walden | |
| September 6 | 2006 | Nathan F. Schott | |
| June 10 | 2006 | Andersen N. Bell | |
| April 3 | 2006 | Collin McCabe | |
| April 3 | 2006 | Nicholas Eastman | |
| February 14 | 2006 | Lance Tuller | |
| January 3 | 2006 | David Kemper Baldwin Allison | |
| September 13 | 2005 | Andrew T. Saunders | |
| September 13 | 2005 | Michael M. Ransdell | |
| August 30 | 2004 | Daniel L. Gibbons | |
| August 30 | 2004 | Sammuel L. Newman | |
| April 10 | 2003 | Jonathan M. Pavlick | |
| February 4 | 2002 | Dan Kuebler | |
| December 4 | 2001 | Jonathan D. Walden | |
| October 10 | 2001 | Edwin B. Wilson | |
| October 10 | 2001 | Eric R. Krogh | |
| September 24 | 2001 | Joseph Michael Leonelli | |
| August 28 | 2001 | Michael P. King | |
| August 6 | 2001 | Thomas J. L. Chelwick | |
| August 6 | 2001 | Kenneth August | |
| November 21 | 2000 | Michael D. Mason, Jr. | |
| November 20 | 2000 | Lee A. Frey | |
| June 8 | 2000 | Jeffrey A. Westlake | |
| December 29 | 1999 | Daniel J. Eck | |
| December 29 | 1999 | Brian S. Canini | |
| November 29 | 1999 | William F. Herbert | |
| March 17 | 1999 | Joshua W. Stegman | |
| February 28 | 1999 | Steven E. Holton | |
| May 1 | 1998 | William R. Tatz | |
| December 30 | 1996 | Sean T. Frey | |
| December 2 | 1996 | John B. Kuebler | |
| December 14 | 1995 | John C. Allen | |
| September 21 | 1995 | Jeffrey S. Wittich | |
| May 22 | 1995 | Joshua M. King | |
| May 15 | 1995 | Travis M. Bott | |
| March 15 | 1995 | Kent D. Keister | |
| September 15 | 1994 | Christopher F. Burke | |
| December 27 | 1992 | Robert E. Fann | |
| September 11 | 1991 | John M. Baker | 3 Silver Palms |
| April 21 | 1965 | David C. Hemmelgarn | |
| April 19 | 1965 | David E. Leppert | |
| October 14 | 1964 | Steven L. Hemmelgarn | |
| January 15 | 1964 | David R. Fredericks | |